8/21/2006

WHO'S BARRING WHOM?

Seeing Asheesh allude to his disagreement with "progressives who think military recruiters should be barred from targeting students on campus," I have to ask: Who is barring military recruiters from targeting students on campus? Because if he's referring to the legal battle between several universities and the Defense Department over the Solomon Ammendment, it's worth noting at the issue at stake is whether the federal government can force private universities receiving federal money to provide military recruiters with access to students as great or greater than that available to other recruiters. The question is not whether universities can bar military recruiters from the premises. The question is whether the federal government can force universities to invite military recruiters to university-sponsored career fairs. While conservatives will tell you that these cases are all about communist academics purging institutions they don't like (watch your back, Central Intelligence Agency), what kept the US military out of the rarified air of the college career fair was its unabashed policy of discrimination against gay people. It's because of the military's discrimination against a class protected by many universities' non-discrimination policies that those universities have chosen not to invite them to use university-sponsored events to recruit only heterosexual students. I can't speak to other universities, but at Yale you can frequently spot recruiters in public spaces on campus. We get Jews for Jesus, too. On some occasions, recruiters have even set up shop in the same indoor space where friends of mine who were Yale students at the time were detained by the police for leafletting. They were not detained by the police. Are other universities driving military recruiters off their streets? Look, I know one or two people who were classmates of mine who believe that military recruiters should be physically barred from all university property. I think they're wrong. And I think some of the left-of-center supporters of the Solomon Amendment are right to be concerned about the division between attendees of elite universities and enrollees in the US military. But it's hard for me to see how forcing open the doors of college career fairs to military recruiters who will only consider heterosexual college students will spark an influx of those students into the service. If that's the goal, forcing open the doors of the military to enrollees of all sexual orientations would be a good start.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home